From chapter 2 "The Education of the Ideological Community"
"One cannot help noticing again and again in British churches that a preacher who speaks in simple, emotive rhetoric with a warm flow of stereotypes is preferred to a preacher who makes a genuine attempt to tackle some real aspect of contemporary Christian life and faith. The preacher, most congregations seem to feel, should not make these kinds of demands upon his listeners. No matter how well educated and successful they may be as professional people in their week-day lives, they will complain of not being able to understand a preacher who encourages them to think, but the one who gives them a cosy feeling of being in a familiar, warm cocoon of accepted beliefs is admired and appreciated. It does not matter to the listeners that they are unable to repeat even the main theme of the sermon five minutes later; the important thing is the comforting emotion of familiarity and belonging which swept over them as they were listening to him. It is this experience, whether conveyed through words, music or ritual, which many church people seem to be referring to when they speak of worship and what it means to them."
Lots of food for thought here for members and leaders of churches. Why are we here and what are we doing?
Showing posts with label Christian education. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Christian education. Show all posts
Friday, March 22, 2013
Thursday, February 21, 2013
What Prevents Christian Adults From Learning (2)
Continuing to read John Hull's book and have now finished chapter 1. Here are some more of the interesting points he makes:
(Page 19) "By studying what a congregation experiences as being distracting, we may often gain a deeper understanding of the problems of adult learning in that congregation. The source of the distraction is the centre of a potential interest which has been ruled illegitimate by the form of spirituality into which the worshipper has been domesticated ... (for example) Congregations where children are found a distraction should stop thinking about their ministry to children and start thinking about the ministry of children to them ... Learning breakthroughs occur when barriers suggested by the experience of distraction are broken through."
(Page 21) "A future without a past is as empty as a past without a future is hopeless. What is needed is a shift in the Christian construct of the past such that the past is seen in a learning perspective... (Page 23) The Christian learner does not only learn the Christian past; he learns from the Christian past. This has important implications for the way in which the Bible is handled in the Christian education of adults today. The important thing is not the world out of which the text came, but the world to which the text points. The meaning of the biblical text is not only to be found in the historical and philological factors which created the text; its meaning also lies in that which the text has since created and may still create."
(Page 24) "Although, as (Christians) look back on their lives, they admit that it could have been different, there is often a strong sense that life has unfolded according to a preconceived divine plan. The Christian, it is thought, must try to get to know this plan, but once he does know it, many of his choices will be settled. Popular attitudes to prayer often suggest this release from responsibility."
Describing how a vicar preached a sermon condemning a TV series called Jesus: The Evidence, before it had even been broadcast, and had warned his congregation not to watch it, Hull writes (Page 37) "From the point of view of education, the Christian believer is here given no alternative to the life of docile, unquestioning obedience, for the life of active enquiry would induce guilt and would be blasphemous. To enquire is to doubt, to doubt is to mock. The world of television and of scholarship may enquire and so mock, but the little flock which is the church trusts and has faith."
Food for thought!
(Page 19) "By studying what a congregation experiences as being distracting, we may often gain a deeper understanding of the problems of adult learning in that congregation. The source of the distraction is the centre of a potential interest which has been ruled illegitimate by the form of spirituality into which the worshipper has been domesticated ... (for example) Congregations where children are found a distraction should stop thinking about their ministry to children and start thinking about the ministry of children to them ... Learning breakthroughs occur when barriers suggested by the experience of distraction are broken through."
(Page 21) "A future without a past is as empty as a past without a future is hopeless. What is needed is a shift in the Christian construct of the past such that the past is seen in a learning perspective... (Page 23) The Christian learner does not only learn the Christian past; he learns from the Christian past. This has important implications for the way in which the Bible is handled in the Christian education of adults today. The important thing is not the world out of which the text came, but the world to which the text points. The meaning of the biblical text is not only to be found in the historical and philological factors which created the text; its meaning also lies in that which the text has since created and may still create."
(Page 24) "Although, as (Christians) look back on their lives, they admit that it could have been different, there is often a strong sense that life has unfolded according to a preconceived divine plan. The Christian, it is thought, must try to get to know this plan, but once he does know it, many of his choices will be settled. Popular attitudes to prayer often suggest this release from responsibility."
Describing how a vicar preached a sermon condemning a TV series called Jesus: The Evidence, before it had even been broadcast, and had warned his congregation not to watch it, Hull writes (Page 37) "From the point of view of education, the Christian believer is here given no alternative to the life of docile, unquestioning obedience, for the life of active enquiry would induce guilt and would be blasphemous. To enquire is to doubt, to doubt is to mock. The world of television and of scholarship may enquire and so mock, but the little flock which is the church trusts and has faith."
Food for thought!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)